I agree with Daniel on this. It's also an issue for /any/ documentation in the handbook - I found a drupal 4.3 site listed in the top level site showcases handbook page the other week. We might want a note somewhere on the parent page making this point very clearly, and the 'last updated' in big letters on the thickbox article might be worth replicating.

On Wed, Jun 4, 2008 at 11:55 PM, Daniel F. Kudwien <news@unleashedmind.com> wrote:
> Are we also committing to keeping these pages up to date?
> Out of date/wrong documentation can be just as bad if not
> worse than no documentation at all.

As a maintainer of a module that is included in one of these comparisons, it's in my interest to update that page to reflect recent changes.  If it's rated poor, and I'll never update the page, it will stay poor (and probably is).

sun