On Apr 17, 2007, at 12:15 PM, Karthik wrote:
I'm looking for constructive feedback as to why this might be good/bad as the default implementation for core.
because it makes it harder for sites that require admin approval (which all of mine do). for example, i added some required profile fields when people request a new account, and i use the additional info to decide if they should be approved or not. it's not clear to me how that would fit in to your proposal. seems like admin approval isn't considered at all, but IMHO, this is critical functionality for Drupal to continue supporting. so, if you're serious about moving this into core, please post a new version of your workflow that shows how and where admin approval fits in. thanks, -derek