I've submitted my SoC 2007 Drupal proposal to Google. Thanks to everybody for the feedback. A formatted PDF version is here: http://www.abeharry.info/SoC2007_DrupalAST_FullProposal.pdf Here is the abstract: The Drupal automated staging toolkit is a proposed set of code libraries, file schemas and parsers, and code generators, for automatically creating a Drupal site with specific module code versions, sample users and data, and a specific LAMP stack configuration for hosting the Drupal site. The toolkit also has the ability to stage this generated site on an existing physical server location, and also as a self-contained virtual machine consisting of a minimal Linux environment, required LAMP software, and the Drupal site. The automated staging toolkit is designed to be part of an automated unit- and regression testing environment, by providing testers with a simple, fast way to automatically generate a complete Drupal site running specific code versions, and using specific LAMP server configurations. It is also intended for use as part of a performance and scalability testing environment by providing the ability to rapidly build and then benchmark the effects of different application, web and database server configurations on Drupal site performance and scalability. This toolkit will be used in the following way: 1. The tester creates or reuses an XML(or other structured) file using a schema describing the Drupal site code-tree, including modules installed/enabled/disabled, and the versions of each module to be used. 2. The tester creates or reuses an XML file using a schema describing the LAMP stack web server, PHP/application server, and database server configuration; e.g Apache vs. Lighttpd, mod_php vs.FastCGI, choice of op-code cache, MySQL vs. PostgreSQL, and so on. 3. The tester creates or reuses an XML file using a schema describing the sample users and content data the site will contain. 4. The parsers take each file and generate scripts in a lightweight language (Python or Ruby or PHP-CLI.) These scripts, when executed, use functions in the code libraries to download Drupal modules, generate database scripts and datasets, and write server configuration files. 5. Given a physical server target location, the Drupal modules, database scripts and server configuration files are deployed to the designated server location, to produce a new, ready-to-test Drupal site. Time and resource permitting, a builder in the toolkit will also use the generated Drupal site and servers' configuration as input to build a self-contained virtual machine image in Xen, VMWare, or potentially the Amazon EC AMI format. This virtual image can also be be used in testing environments, including advanced performance testing scenarios such as evaluating clustering, distributed database topologies, and alternative storage and computing models like Amazon S3 and Elastic Cloud. The ability to rapidly generate self-contained Drupal virtual machine images will also be extremely valuable to Drupal consultants and solution providers for marketing, prototyping and demonstrating Drupal solutions to potential clients, and large organizations and ASPs like CivicSpace looking to take advantage of the massive benefits of virtualization technology from VMware, Xensource, Amazon, and the like. Allister. On 19/03/07, KevinImNotSpacey <kevin.amerson@gmail.com> wrote:
Hey Allister,
I can't speak to Google SoC requirements, but your idea sounds great. I could see some code being written to automate setting up the environment, perhaps that could be the focus. I know there is a set of repetitive tasks that we go through whenever evaluating a new module or upgrading an existing one:
1) Get the module from drupal.org 2) Stage our database and other contrib modules 3) Copy over the module code and enable it through the admin UI 4) Test expected behaviors
A separate but somewhat related question/task/complicated activity is moving changes between environments, such as moving a discrete change from dev -> integration -> test -> production. There is a module called importexportapi that does some of this, but no real complete solution. Perhaps your project could include a methodology + utility to allow us to hot deploy drupal changes to a prod environment.
Kevin
On 3/19/07, Allister Beharry <allister.beharry@gmail.com> wrote:
Thanks for the heads-up Robert. I've been reading the SoC project proposal for automating testing of patches, and also your posts on a performance and scalability testing environment for Drupal. Virtual machine images have been posited as part of an solution for both. So I'm going to channel Laskey wrt my original idea and propose a better one. (I'm just punching this out before I race to class so it's gonna be brief/fragmented with typos. I'll elaborate further when I get back.)
A key requirement of automated testing of Drupal is the ability to create a Drupal site with a specific configuration. In the case of unit testing patches and code and also regression testing, the Drupal site must be running specfic versions of core and module code. Now automating tests is one thing but at the end-of-the day a human will have to be able to eyeball a Drupal site with specific versions of core and module code. There needs to be an automated way for a tester to create a complete Drupal sit by simply specifiying what code versions he/she wants running
For performance and scalability testing,a human tester will want to vary things like choice of web server - Apache, lightpd, IIS - choice of db - MySQL, PostgreSQL - PHP configuration - mod_pho, FastCGI, PHP enhancements like APC, Zend optimizer, reverse proxies, as well as varying load parameters for the Drupal site as you mentioned - number of core/contrib modules, number of databases, memcache, database topography, so on. You'll also need to populate the db with sample content and user account. For testing on Amazon EC you'd need an AMI image
What is needed is some kind of interface or configuration script that a tester can use to quickly generate a Drupal site configured with these parameters. The script interpreter would take a configuration script and a designated target, and spit out: 1. A ready to run tarball with drupal settings.php + php.ini + database script thatcan be immediately deployed to an existing web + database server setup 2. A virtual machine image in either VMWare or Xen or AMI format.
Well it sounds kind of ambitious, but even if done on a scaled back way, could have applications well outside Drupal. What do you think?
Allister.
On 19/03/07, Robert Douglass <rob@robshouse.net> wrote:
Allister,
before I discuss your idea, it should be noted that you can't propose a GSoC project which doesn't produce code. As you describe it, your idea is mostly a task for a sysadmin and doesn't produce code, therefore wouldn't be eligible for the program.
Your idea, however, is very good. I had envisioned a similar use of virtual images here: http://groups.drupal.org/node/2742 The problem with doing my idea as GSoC is that it is more than one person could reasonably manage, I think, and is dependent on infrastructure that we're not in a position to provide.
I think what is needed is some brainstorming that combines your software appliance with performance, scalability and regression testing. Please chew on these ideas and come up with an alternate proposal. We'd love to have you apply to GSoC with a Drupal project.
cheers,
Robert
Allister Beharry wrote:
Hello all, I'll be participating in SoC 07 and I'd appreciate it if I can get some feedback on my idea for a project with Drupal. Here is the synopsis:
My project idea for SoC 2007 is a Drupal software appliance – a self-contained virtual image consisting of a minimal Linux environment, a LAMP stack, and Drupal 5.1 – which can be distributed as a bootable LiveCD or virtual machine image which can be run on virtualization software like VMware Player or MS Virtual PC.
At ~50Mb or less, a Drupal appliance is a perfect way for potential users with no system administration experience to evaluate Drupal. Advocacy for Drupal can be extended by distributing the Live CD with magazines and in trade shows. Drupal companies and consultants can rapidly prototype and demonstrate a Drupal a solution to their clients starting with the base appliance image. Drupal admins can easily test module patches before deployment to live sites. The virtual machine image can also be part of an automated testing framework by utilizing the scripting capabilities of virtualization software like VMware Server.
This project can build on existing LiveDistro images from Knoppix or Damn Small Linux, and virtual appliance images like those from Virtual Appliance ( http://virtualappliances.net/products/lamp/). The main tasks will be: 1.Collecting requirements from the Drupal community; 2.Building the target environment; 3.Installing and integrating Drupal and necessary modules; 4.Comprehensive testing of the entire appliance; 5.Coding hooks in the virtualization software for use of the appliance by automated testing tools; 6.Promotion and obtaining distribution channels for the release of the appliance.
Thanks a lot. Allister
-- * * * * * Lullabot's First Ever Advanced Workshops Are Here! Drupal API & Module Building - Advanced Drupal Themeing April 9th-13th - Providence, RI Early Bird Discounts Available Now http://www.lullabot.com/training * * * * *