Hi Romeu, When did we used the word "quality" as an excuse to hold the "power" to approve? Do you have any proof of that? As far as I remember, last time when I discussed about Pedro becoming maintainer of the translation he told me that he wasn't interested. BTW, could you introduce yourself? Your acc is just 1 week and 3 days old, you haven't made any comment in drupal.org, neither groups.drupal.org, you don't appear to have an acc in drupal-br.org. Your last comment in l.d.o was extremely unkind (http://localize.drupal.org/node/192#comment-290). And by this time, you haven't sent any suggestion in l.d.o. Cheers, Fabiano Sant'Ana On Mon, Sep 28, 2009 at 2:01 PM, Romeu(ilux) <medivih@gmail.com> wrote:

About Quality I agree, but please don´t turn "Quality" in an excuse to hold "power" of approve. Therefore, pedrofaria have 88 suggestions approved and you have 16, so i think you can´t understimate him. I think he can do with quality too. Looking at your own arguee you can simply add pedrofaria, and we can do Quality and Quantity as well. And if the discussion is long for me means theres no solution, and you can´t achive new results if you are acting as same.

I will open, a new thread for sure there. BUT I will not MOVE this.

If you think it´s not a "plain" solution and we still have issue, why keep sameness?

About Event it´s already in my schedule, thank you for kindness.

On Mon, Sep 28, 2009 at 12:26 PM, Fabiano Sant'Ana <listas@wundo.net> wrote:

...

Hi Romeu,

There is a long discussion back there in l.d.o about Quality of Translation versus Number of Translated Strings, please take a look. Just adding more maintainers is not a plain solution for the translation problem, IMHO having a bad translation is much worse than no translation.

Also, I don't think this list is the proper place to discuss this issue, as most of the team involved in the translation are not subscribed to this list, please open a new thread (or comment in an existing one) in  l.d.o.

BTW, we will have a big Drupal event down in Campinas in the end of October, I would be glad if you could be joining us. Cheers, Fabiano Sant'Ana

On Mon, Sep 28, 2009 at 12:07 PM, Romeu(ilux) <medivih@gmail.com> wrote:

...

Thank you for fast answer.

Well, my great idea it´s too simple, just add more maintainers. As you said, look at top 5 approved suggestions:

Top contributors

People with most approved translations

Initial transla... - 4718 translations zsanmartin - 401 translations (Already Mantainer) pedrofaria - 88 translations aleagi - 60 translations thiagomoraesp - 33 translations lourenzo - 18 translations

Like pedrofaria, aleagi, and simple add as maintainer. Sure, we need first ask them if they agree, but i can assure they will.

Quite simple, quite easy and fair with Brazilians Drupal users.

Theres a lot of ready material wating to be approved.

Sorry if i was not so clear, I just want to contribute to spread Drupal "Using". Unfortunely Brazilians are half educaded in english and we need portuguese language for develop.

Best Wishes, Romeu F Mello

On Mon, Sep 28, 2009 at 8:33 AM, Fabiano Sant'Ana <listas@wundo.net> wrote:

...

Hi Romeu, Did you took a look at our discussion page in l.d.o?

First thing, I'm not the only one with approval role in our group.

Second, it is not true that I only approve my translations. You (and everyone interested) can check it yourself, open this page http://localize.drupal.org/translate/languages/pt-br and see that I'm only in the fifth position in the top contributors list.

Also, by your message doesn't seem that you even took a look in the pt-br l.d.o discussions page, as there is an discussion there about this topic, and it has been decided that the members who have the most approved suggestions will become maintainers (http://localize.drupal.org/node/80).

If you don't agree with this process you're welcome to submit your idea about how the process should be.

Cheers, Fabiano Sant'Ana

On Mon, Sep 28, 2009 at 4:38 AM, Gábor Hojtsy <gabor@hojtsy.hu> wrote:

...

Why not ask Wundo himself?

Gábor

On Sun, Sep 27, 2009 at 9:53 PM,  <romeufmello@gmail.com> wrote:

...

romeufmello sent a message using the contact form at http://drupal.org/contact.

Our administrator in localize.drupal.org Brazilian team are WUNDO... and he dont aprove another translations.. he only aprove his own translations... and we have more suggestion than untraslated.. so we are stucked.

I think you have to consider to add another administrators to aprove... more open source way... more fair.

Sorry my terrible english. That why i need the translation files... we have suggestions to be aproved since February. I Think its became slow, and unfair... Please Solve this in some way.

Best Regards.

_______________________________________________ translations mailing list translations@drupal.org http://lists.drupal.org/mailman/listinfo/translations