[support] Comment forms will not open on new page

[Michael Prasuhn]

So are you saying there is NO form at all when you are viewing the url  
'comment/reply/9#comment-form'?

Or are you saying that the comment form is also displayed on the  
regular view of the content?

The option for 'display on separate page' vs. 'display below post or  
comments' simply controls where the add comment form is visible. When  
it is set to 'display below', every post that has comments enabled,  
will have the comment form added automatically when you are viewing  
that content. If it is set to 'dispay on separate page' when viewing  
any piece of content with comments enabled, the add a comment form  
will not be shown, but simply a link, that will take the user to a  
page that shows the content with the form below, in the style of the  
first item.

On other words, 'display on separate page' means, don't display the  
form by default, but but a link to a page where a comment can be added.


But if you are really getting no comment form on the 'comment/reply/ 
9#comment-form' page, they you have something very wrong with your  
system.

-Mike
__________________
Michael Prasuhn
mike at mikeyp.net
http://mikeyp.net
949.200.7595
714.356.0168 cell
949.200.7670 fax


On Dec 14, 2007, at 2:58 PM, Michelle Cox wrote:

> Never had this happen... I pretty much always have it set to show on  
> another
> page so you have to click a link to comment.
>
> Michelle
>
>
> On 12/14/2007 4:53:51 PM, Eric Mckenna (eric.mckenna at gmail.com) wrote:
>> This is just killing me...
>> I've tried on two different drupal servers
>> running 5.5 and comments just do not open in a new window.  I have  
>> to be
>> missing something or this is a bug.  Can anyone else confirm this  
>> problem?
>>
>> Eric McKenna wrote:
>>> I appear to be getting the correct url,
>>> "comment/reply/9#comment-form", but no new form.
>>>
>>>
>> My comment form will not open on a new page.  The admin comment  
>> settings
>> for location is set to "Display on separate page", but it never does.
>> Is this a bug or what?  I'm
>> using a bunch CCK types but even when I used
>> a basic page type the comment form always appeared at the bottom.
>>
>> eric.
>> --
>> [ Drupal support list | http://lists.drupal.org/ ]
>
> -- 
> [ Drupal support list | http://lists.drupal.org/ ]